Monday to Saturday, 8 am to 5 pm. Sunday closed.
CA India Arpan Bohra & Co., Chartered Accountants

GST Case Law

GSTAT Recent Judgements: Five Tribunal Orders Every GST Litigator Should Read (Series, Part 1)

The GST Appellate Tribunal is now deciding second appeals across benches, and its orders are starting to show how it will treat recurring departmental positions. This first part of the series picks five recent orders that matter for notice replies and appeal grounds.

Note: These are tribunal orders reported in the press. Several reports do not state the date of the order or name every party; where so, this is mentioned. Please read the order before relying on it.

At a glance

Case Bench Point decided
R.K. Enterprises v. K S Chahal Chandigarh Bench, 12 November (APL/169/CHD/2026) Section 130 confiscation of goods in transit needs a link to the detained goods; past ITC doubts alone do not suffice
Revenue appeal (taxpayer unnamed in report) Bengaluru Bench Audit-triggered disclosure is not voluntary; tax paid without interest does not earn penalty relief
Grace Book Centre Prayagraj Bench One-day survey sales cannot be extrapolated to nine months of turnover without evidence
Prasanna Enterprises (respondent) Chandigarh Bench Export refund cannot be denied only because goods were exported after the invoice period
Reliance Jio Infocomm Ltd. v. various authorities (TRNS.OF.APPL/10/PB/2026) Principal Bench 22 appeals on ITC for telecom towers transferred to the Principal Bench under Section 109(6)

1. Confiscation under Section 130 needs a link to the goods

GST officers intercepted a consignment of aluminium scrap in transit. The driver produced the invoice, e-way bill, goods receipt and weighment slip, yet the goods and vehicle were confiscated on doubts about the taxpayer’s earlier purchases and suppliers. The Chandigarh Bench (Jatinder Pal Singh, Judicial Member, and Pradeep Kumar Goel, Technical Member) held that confiscation under Section 130 requires a violation connected to the detained consignment. No defect was found in the accompanying documents, and the Department showed no link between the earlier inward supplies and the goods detained. The Tribunal said it was examining the legality of confiscation, not the correctness of ITC claims, and set aside the confiscation and the Section 122 penalty.

Practical use: In transit cases, test whether the notice alleges any defect in the consignment itself, and whether ITC reversal was ever sought in the notice or order.

2. Audit-triggered disclosure and penalty relief (Bengaluru)

On a Revenue appeal, the Bengaluru Bench (Srikanth Venkatraman, Judicial Member, and Sudha Koka, Technical Member) dealt with a services provider audited for July 2017 to March 2020. For a gap between GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B, it accepted that the supplies were disclosed, so Section 74 suppression could not rest on them, but held that paying tax without interest after more than three years did not meet conditions for penalty relief. For receipts disclosed in GSTR-9 only after audit scrutiny, it found the disclosure was not voluntary and restored the Section 74 penalty. Total penalties confirmed were about ₹22.62 lakh. Procedural objections, including a missing DIN on the Section 112(3) authorisation, were rejected.

Practical use: Pay interest along with tax when seeking penalty relief, and note the Tribunal’s distinction between disclosed-but-unpaid tax and amounts disclosed only after audit.

3. Estimates from a one-day survey (Prayagraj)

A State Tax survey of a Prayagraj partnership firm trading in books and stationery recorded about ₹70,000 in sales, and the Department extended that to the preceding nine months and raised a Section 74 demand. The Prayagraj Bench held that one day’s sales cannot be used to estimate nine months’ turnover without supporting evidence, and that a Section 74 demand based on estimates cannot stand without corroboration and proof of actual evasion. The demand of about ₹3.10 lakh was set aside.

4. Export refund and timing of export (Chandigarh)

For a refund of accumulated ITC on exports under bond or LUT for July 2022, the Chandigarh Bench held that goods invoiced within the refund period can count toward zero-rated supply turnover under Rule 89(4) even if physically exported later, provided actual export is established. The report does not state the exact operative order; read the order for the relief granted.

5. Principal Bench consolidates 22 appeals

The Principal Bench, exercising powers under Section 109(6), transferred 22 appeals by Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited, against orders of various State appellate authorities on refunds of ITC reversed under protest, to itself, noting an identical question of law on ITC eligibility for telecom towers. This shows how common questions across states may be centralised.

How to use these orders

  • Orders of a Bench are persuasive for other Benches and are not a substitute for statute; cite them with the bench and date.
  • Several matters turn on the notice itself; compare with the Supreme Court’s August 2026 rulings on Section 74 foundational facts, discussed in our earlier article.
  • Check limitation, pre-deposit and condonation rules for second appeals before filing.

Frequently asked questions

1. Do GSTAT orders bind other Benches?
They are persuasive; treat each as the view of that Bench.

2. Can goods be confiscated because of doubts about earlier ITC?
Per the Chandigarh Bench, not without evidence linking those transactions to the detained goods.

3. Does paying tax before the notice avoid penalty?
Not automatically. The Bengaluru Bench held that tax paid without interest did not satisfy the conditions.

4. Can turnover be estimated from a survey?
Not from one day’s sales alone, per the Prayagraj Bench, without corroboration.

5. Where is the next part?
Further parts will follow as more orders are reported.

Sources

This article is for general educational purposes and is not advice on any particular matter. Facts of each case differ.

Arpan Bohra & Co., Chartered Accountants, Himayat Nagar, Hyderabad
Website: https://www.arpanbohra.co.in/ · Email: office@arpanbohra.co.in · Phone: 9010558981

This article is for general information and is not professional advice. Law and rates change; please consult us before you act.

we reply within one working day

Have a question on tax, audit or compliance?

WhatsApp us
Call WhatsApp Book