A taxpayer in Hyderabad receives a show cause notice for 2018-19 in June 2025. The notice says the demand arose by “fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts”, but does not say what was concealed, or how. Is the extended five-year period available to the department?
Short answer: No. In two August 2026 decisions, a Supreme Court bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran held that Section 74 of the CGST Act cannot be invoked by reciting those words. The notice itself must set out the foundational facts that led the officer to infer fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression.
The two decisions
| G.R. Infra Projects Ltd. v. State of Madhya Pradesh | Tata Steel Ltd. v. Union of India | |
|---|---|---|
| Decided | 19 August 2026 | 25 August 2026 |
| Reference | Civil Appeal No. 11277 of 2026 | 2026 INSC 920 |
| Period / notice | FY 2018-19; SCN dated 13 June 2025 | FY 2018-19 to 2020-21; SCN dated 13 June 2025 (arising from an audit objection) |
| Outcome | SCN and High Court order set aside | SCN and Order-in-Original dated 26 December 2025 set aside |
Why Section 73 versus Section 74 matters
Section 73 covers cases without fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression and carries the shorter limitation. Section 74 covers cases of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax and carries the longer period. Section 74A, which applies to later periods (FY 2024-25 onwards), is outside these rulings. Because limitation is the department’s main reason for choosing Section 74, a notice that is late under Section 73 survives only if Section 74 is validly invoked.
In both cases the notices were issued on 13 June 2025, after the Section 73 period had run out (28 February 2025 after pandemic-era exclusion, as the Court computed for the years in dispute). So everything depended on Section 74.
What the Court held
- Reciting the words is not enough. A notice must disclose the facts from which the officer concluded that fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression occurred. Mechanical use of the phrases suggests the officer did not apply his mind.
- The notice must stand on its own. In G.R. Infra, the Court declined to consider the State’s counter affidavit to fill the gap. A defective notice cannot be cured by later explanation in court.
- Officer’s satisfaction is required. In Tata Steel, the Court looked for the proper officer’s own satisfaction on the alleged fraud or suppression behind the mismatch or short payment, and found the audit-objection trail did not show it.
- Section 73(10) governs the order, not the notice. The argument that starting proceedings before Section 73 limitation expired saved the notice was rejected.
- Explanation 2 to Section 74 did not help. The Court rejected reliance on it because it was omitted with effect from 1 November 2024.
- Fresh Section 74 proceedings in Tata Steel, with conditions. The Department may begin afresh only if the foundational facts appear on the face of the notice, and the order must be passed by 28 February 2027.
Practical checklist for a notice reply
| Check | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Section invoked | Is it Section 74 or only a label? Compare with the narrative. |
| Facts of fraud or suppression | Does the notice say what was suppressed, and why it shows intent to evade tax? |
| Date of notice vs Section 73 period | Compute the Section 73 time limit for the year, including applicable extensions. |
| Officer’s satisfaction | Is there any record of the officer’s own satisfaction, or only an audit objection? |
| Mismatch alone | A return mismatch or ITC difference does not by itself establish fraud or suppression. |
| Where to raise it | Raise it in the reply, then in appeal. If a High Court writ is considered, weigh the alternate remedy. |
Limits of the rulings
- The decisions concern notices under Sections 73 and 74 for earlier years. Whether the same reasoning applies under Section 74A is an arguable position, not yet settled.
- They do not say a notice with specific facts of suppression will fail. A well-pleaded Section 74 notice still has to be answered on merits.
- Limitation depends on the due date of the annual return and the pandemic extensions for that year. Check each year separately.
Hyderabad and Telangana context
The Telangana GST Act follows the CGST Act, so the principle applies to notices issued by State officers as well as Central officers. Businesses in Hitech City, Gachibowli and Kondapur that received audit-based notices for 2018-19 to 2020-21 should review the notice date and its factual narrative against these rulings.
Frequently asked questions
1. Does the Supreme Court say Section 74 can never apply after the Section 73 period?
No. It says Section 74 requires foundational facts of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression in the notice itself.
2. Can the department fix a weak notice by filing an affidavit in court?
In G.R. Infra, the Court declined to use a counter affidavit to supply the missing basis.
3. Does a GSTR-3B and GSTR-2A/2B mismatch prove suppression?
Not by itself. The notice must explain why the mismatch shows suppression with intent to evade tax.
4. Can the department issue a fresh notice?
In Tata Steel, the Court permitted fresh Section 74 proceedings on stated conditions. Availability in another matter depends on its own limitation position.
5. Where should this ground be raised?
First in the reply to the show cause notice and, if needed, in appeal; confirm the correct forum for the facts.
Sources
- Supreme Court of India, Tata Steel Ltd. v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 920, as reported by Verdictum and LiveLaw
- Supreme Court of India, G.R. Infra Projects Ltd. v. State of Madhya Pradesh, CA 11277 of 2026, as reported by LiveLaw
- Supreme Court Observer case summary of Tata Steel
This article is for general educational purposes and is not advice on any particular notice. Facts of each case differ.
Arpan Bohra & Co., Chartered Accountants, Himayat Nagar, Hyderabad
Website: https://www.arpanbohra.co.in/ · Email: office@arpanbohra.co.in · Phone: 9010558981
This article is for general information and is not professional advice. Law and rates change; please consult us before you act.